Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

Should You Buy AAA Member Loyalty Accident Insurance

What AAA Member Loyalty Accident Insurance Actually Covers

AAA Member Loyalty Accident Insurance is an optional add-on policy that AAA members can purchase to cover costs that standard auto insurance often leaves uncovered after a crash. It typically pays for things like rental car reimbursement, towing and labor, glass repair, and sometimes medical payments or lost wages — depending on which coverage tier you choose.

The key word here is "optional." This is not something your state requires you to carry, and it is not something your regular auto insurance policy automatically includes. You have to decide whether to buy it, and that decision depends on what gaps exist in your current coverage and how much you are willing to spend each month to fill them.

AAA offers this through their membership, so you need to be a member to purchase it. The coverage is underwritten by an insurance company (which varies by state), but AAA handles the enrollment and claims process. It is marketed as a way to protect yourself from the financial strain that follows an accident — the rental car costs, the deductible you owe, the time you lose from work.

Key Takeaways

  • AAA Member Loyalty Accident Insurance covers specific costs after a crash that your regular auto insurance may not pay for, such as rental cars, towing, and sometimes medical expenses or lost wages.
  • You can only buy this coverage if you are an AAA member, and it costs between roughly $10 and $30 per month depending on the coverage level and your state.
  • Before buying it, check what your existing auto insurance already covers — many policies include rental reimbursement and towing, which would make this add-on redundant.
  • This insurance pays you directly for covered expenses, not the other party or their insurer, so it only helps if you are at fault or hit by an uninsured driver.
  • The coverage has limits and exclusions, so read the specific policy document for your state to understand what is actually covered and what you would still pay out of pocket.

How Much It Costs and What You Actually Get

The monthly premium for AAA Member Loyalty Accident Insurance varies by state and by the coverage tier you select. Most members pay somewhere between $10 and $30 per month, though some states and coverage combinations fall outside that range. AAA typically offers two or three tiers — a basic option that covers rental reimbursement and towing, and higher tiers that add medical payments, lost wages, or other benefits.

When you file a claim, you pay the covered expense out of pocket and then submit a receipt to AAA for reimbursement. For example, if your car is in the shop for three days and you rent a car for $60 per day, you would pay the rental company $180, then submit the receipt to AAA. They would reimburse you up to the daily limit stated in your policy — often $30 to $50 per day, with a total limit of $900 to $1,500 per claim.

The same structure applies to other covered expenses. You pay the tow truck driver, the glass repair shop, or the medical provider, and then request reimbursement from AAA. This means you need cash or credit available at the time of the expense, which is important to know if you are already stretched financially after an accident.

Compare This to What Your Current Insurance Already Covers

Before you decide whether to buy this add-on, pull out your auto insurance policy and look for these sections: rental reimbursement, towing and labor, and medical payments. Many standard auto policies already include at least one of these, and some include all three.

Rental reimbursement is extremely common in modern auto policies. If your insurer already covers rental cars at $30 or $40 per day, buying AAA's rental coverage would be paying twice for the same thing. The same applies to towing — most policies cover towing to the nearest repair shop, sometimes up to $100 or $150 per incident.

Medical payments coverage is less universal but still fairly common, especially in states that do not require it. If your policy includes medical payments, it pays for injuries to you and your passengers regardless of who caused the accident. AAA's version does the same thing, so again, you would be duplicating coverage.

The honest move is to call your insurance agent or log into your policy online and ask directly: "What does my policy cover after an accident, and what does it not cover?" Write down the specific limits for each type of coverage. Then compare that list to what AAA is offering. If your policy already covers the things AAA is selling, the add-on is not worth the monthly cost.

When This Coverage Actually Helps You

AAA Member Loyalty Accident Insurance is most useful if you are at fault in an accident or hit by an uninsured driver. In those situations, your own insurance pays for your car repairs, but the other party's insurance does not pay for your rental car, your medical bills, or your lost wages. That is where the AAA add-on steps in.

It also helps if your regular insurance has high deductibles or low limits. For example, if your policy covers rental cars but only up to $25 per day and you need a rental for a week, you would pay $175 out of pocket. If AAA's coverage reimburses you at $40 per day, that gap matters.

The coverage is less useful if you have comprehensive and collision insurance with low deductibles, high rental limits, and medical payments already included. In that case, you are paying for protection you already have.

The Limits and Exclusions You Need to Know

Like all insurance policies, AAA Member Loyalty Accident Insurance has a list of things it will not pay for. The policy document for your state will spell these out, but common exclusions include accidents caused by drunk driving, racing, or using the car for commercial purposes. If you were at fault because you were impaired, AAA will likely deny the claim.

There are also per-incident and per-year limits. You might have a $1,500 limit on rental reimbursement per accident, and a $3,000 annual limit across all claims. Once you hit those limits, you pay for anything beyond that yourself. The policy document will state these clearly, so read it before you buy.

Deductibles explore to some coverages but not others. Rental reimbursement typically has no deductible — you get reimbursed for the full amount up to the limit. But medical payments or lost wages coverage might have a deductible of $250 or $500, meaning you pay that amount before AAA starts reimbursing you.

Questions to Ask Before You Buy

Start with your insurance agent. Ask them what your current policy covers after an accident, what the limits are, and what it does not cover. Get this in writing if possible — a screenshot of your policy details or an email confirmation.

Then contact AAA directly or visit their website for your state. Request the full policy document for the coverage tier you are considering, not just a summary. Read the section on covered expenses, limits, deductibles, and exclusions. If anything is unclear, call and ask a representative to explain it.

Ask yourself: Am I likely to use this? If you drive rarely, have a short commute, or have a second car you can use while yours is being repaired, the rental reimbursement might never pay out. If you have good health insurance and no dependents, medical payments coverage might be unnecessary. Be honest about your actual risk and your actual needs.

Finally, do the math. If the monthly premium is $20 and you would need to file a claim to break even, how many years would you need to go without an accident for the cost to outweigh the benefit? If the answer is more than five or ten years, and you are a safe driver, the add-on may not be worth it.

Alternatives to Consider

If you decide AAA's add-on is too expensive or redundant with your current coverage, there are other ways to protect yourself financially after an accident. The most straightforward is to increase the rental reimbursement limit on your existing auto policy. This usually costs just a few dollars more per month and covers the same thing without the extra layer of insurance.

You can also build an emergency fund specifically for accident-related expenses. If you set aside $50 per month, you would have $600 in a year — enough to cover a week of rental car costs or a deductible. This requires discipline, but it gives you flexibility and does not lock you into a monthly payment.

Some credit cards offer rental car coverage as a cardholder benefit, especially premium cards. If you have one of these, you might already be covered for rental cars when you use that card to book the rental. Check your card's benefits guide to see what is included.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use AAA Member Loyalty Accident Insurance if the other driver was at fault?

Yes, but it is usually not your first choice. If the other driver's insurance is liable, their insurer should pay for your rental car and medical bills. You would file a claim with their insurer first. AAA's coverage is a backup if the other driver is uninsured or underinsured, or if their insurer denies your claim.

Do I have to be an AAA member to buy this insurance?

Yes. This coverage is only available to AAA members. If you are not a member, you cannot purchase it. AAA membership itself has a separate annual cost, usually around $50 to $150 depending on the membership level.

How long does it take to get reimbursed after I file a claim?

Processing times vary by state and by the complexity of the claim, but AAA typically processes straightforward claims within two to four weeks. You will need to submit receipts and proof of the expense, so have those ready when you file.

What happens if I let my AAA membership lapse?

If you stop being an AAA member, your Member Loyalty Accident Insurance coverage ends. You would no longer be able to file new claims, though claims you filed before your membership ended would still be processed.

Is this the same as roadside information coverage?

No. Roadside information covers things like towing, lockouts, and jump-starts when your car breaks down. AAA Member Loyalty Accident Insurance covers expenses that follow an accident, like rental cars and medical bills. They are separate products, though AAA membership often includes basic roadside information at no extra cost.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.