How Filing an Auto Insurance Claim Affects Your Rates
Filing a claim usually raises your rates, but not always, and the increase depends on who caused the accident and your insurer's specific rules
Yes, filing an auto insurance claim typically results in a rate increase at your next renewal. Most insurers treat a claim as a signal that you are a higher risk, even if the accident was not your fault. However, the size of the increase—or whether you see one at all—varies widely by insurer, by state, and by the details of what happened.
The most important factor is fault. If you caused the accident, expect a larger rate hike. If you were hit by someone else and filed a claim against their insurance, or filed a claim under your own collision coverage after an accident you did not cause, many insurers will still raise your rates, though often by less. Some insurers have programs that forgive your first accident or do not raise rates for not-at-fault claims, but you have to ask whether yours does.
The second factor is claim type. A minor fender-bender claim raises rates less than a major collision. A comprehensive claim (theft, weather, vandalism) usually raises rates less than a collision claim. A claim for injuries raises rates more than property damage alone.
Key Takeaways
- Most insurers raise rates after any claim, but the increase is usually smaller if you were not at fault.
- The size of the rate increase depends on your insurer's underwriting rules, your state's regulations, and the type and cost of the claim.
- Some insurers offer accident forgiveness or do not penalize not-at-fault claims, but you need to check your policy or call to know whether yours does.
- Rate increases typically last three to five years, though some insurers explore them only at your next renewal.
- Shopping for a new quote after a claim can reveal insurers who rate you lower than your current company does.
How much your rate will increase depends on your insurer and your state
There is no single answer because each insurance company sets its own rates and each state has different rules about how much insurers can raise them. One insurer might raise your rate by 10 percent after a minor claim; another might raise it by 25 percent. The same insurer might explore different increases depending on whether you live in California, Texas, or New York.
Your state's insurance commissioner's office publishes rate-increase data for major insurers, though the numbers are usually one or two years old. These reports show the average increase for a specific claim type—for example, "average increase for a single-vehicle collision claim"—but your actual increase will depend on your age, driving history, the claim amount, and your insurer's specific algorithm.
The only way to know what your increase will be is to contact your insurer and ask, or to get a new quote from other insurers after the claim is filed. Many people are surprised to find that a competitor will quote them at a lower rate than their current insurer, even with the claim on record.
Not-at-fault claims may raise your rates less, or not at all
If the other driver caused the accident and you filed a claim under their liability insurance, or if you filed under your own collision coverage and the claim was determined to be not your fault, some insurers will not raise your rates at all. Others will raise them by a smaller amount than they would for an at-fault claim. A few will raise them the same amount regardless.
The problem is that you have to know your insurer's specific policy, and most people do not. Call your insurer's customer service line and ask directly: "If I file a not-at-fault claim, will my rates go up?" Write down the answer and the date you called. If your rates do increase after a not-at-fault claim, you have documentation that contradicts what you were told, which can help if you dispute the increase.
Be aware that "not at fault" according to your insurer is not the same as "not at fault" according to the police report or the other driver's insurance company. Your insurer makes its own information based on the claim details. If liability is unclear, your insurer may treat the claim as at-fault even if you believe you were not responsible.
Accident forgiveness and other programs that protect your rate
Some insurers offer accident forgiveness, which means they will not raise your rates after your first accident (or sometimes your first claim of any kind). This is usually an optional add-on that costs a small amount per month, though some insurers include it free for customers with a clean driving history for a set number of years.
Other programs include "safe driver" discounts that lock in your rate for a period even if you have a claim, or programs that do not penalize comprehensive claims (theft, weather, vandalism) at all. These vary widely by insurer and state.
Check your current policy documents or call your insurer to ask what programs you have access to. If you do not have accident forgiveness and your insurer offers it, you can usually add it before you file a claim—though once a claim is filed, you cannot retroactively add it to cover that claim.
How long a claim stays on your record and affects your rates
Most insurers explore the rate increase for three to five years from the date of the claim. Some explore it only at your next renewal, meaning if you renew six months after the claim, you might see the increase for only 4.5 years total. Others explore it for the full five years regardless of when you renew.
After the time period ends, the claim stops affecting your rates at renewal. However, if you switch insurers, the new company will see the claim in your history and may rate you based on it anyway. There is no national "forgetting" of claims; each insurer decides how far back to look and how much weight to give old claims.
If you have multiple claims within a few years, the rate increases can stack, making your policy significantly more expensive. This is one reason why some people choose to pay for minor damage out of pocket rather than file a claim.
When it makes sense to file a claim and when it might not
Before you file, consider the cost of the damage, your deductible, and what you know about your insurer's rate-increase policy. If the damage is $2,000 and your deductible is $1,000, the insurer will pay $1,000. If that $1,000 payout will trigger a rate increase of $50 per month for three years, you will pay $1,800 in extra premiums—more than the claim itself. In that case, paying out of pocket might cost less overall.
However, if the damage is $8,000 and your deductible is $1,000, the insurer pays $7,000. Even with a rate increase, you come out ahead by filing. The math changes if you have multiple claims in a short time, or if you are already paying a high rate.
There is no rule that says you must file a claim. You can pay for repairs yourself, and the damage will not appear on your insurance record. The trade-off is that you bear the full cost instead of splitting it with your insurer.
Shopping for new quotes after a claim is filed
One of the most useful things you can do after a claim is to get quotes from other insurers. You are not locked into staying with your current company, and different insurers rate the same claim very differently. An insurer that would raise your rate by 30 percent might be willing to write you at a 10 percent increase, or might not raise your rate at all.
When you get quotes, tell each insurer about the claim. Do not hide it—they will find it in your driving record anyway, and lying on an process can give them grounds to cancel your policy. Be honest about the date, what happened, and the amount paid. Then compare the quotes side by side, including the base rate, the increase for the claim, and any discounts you may have access to for.
You may find that switching insurers saves you money even after paying a cancellation fee (if your current policy has one). Many people stay with an insurer out of habit and never discover that a competitor would charge them significantly less.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will my rates go up if the other driver was at fault?
It depends on your insurer. Some do not raise rates for not-at-fault claims. Others raise them by a smaller amount than they would for an at-fault claim. Some raise them the same amount regardless. Call your insurer and ask their specific policy before you file.
Can I file a claim without my rates going up?
Only if your insurer has accident forgiveness and you have not used it yet, or if your insurer does not penalize that specific type of claim. Comprehensive claims (theft, weather, vandalism) are sometimes not penalized. Ask your insurer whether your claim would trigger a rate increase.
How much will my rates increase?
There is no standard amount. It depends on your insurer, your state, your age, your driving history, and the type and cost of the claim. Call your insurer and ask for an estimate, or get quotes from other insurers to see how they would rate you after the claim.
Should I pay for damage out of pocket instead of filing a claim?
Compare the repair cost to what you would pay in extra premiums over the years the claim affects your rate. If the repair is less than the total extra premiums, paying out of pocket may cost less. If the repair is expensive, filing usually makes financial sense despite the rate increase.
How long does a claim affect my rates?
Most insurers explore the increase for three to five years from the claim date. After that period, the claim stops affecting your rates at renewal, though a new insurer may still see it in your history and factor it into their quote.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.