How Filing a Car Insurance Claim Affects Your Rates
Filing a claim usually raises your rates, but not always, and the increase depends on who caused the accident and what your policy covers
When you file a claim, your insurer sees you as a higher risk than before. Most insurers raise rates after a claim—sometimes by 10 to 40 percent, depending on the type of claim and your state. But the increase is not automatic. If someone else caused the accident and your insurer recovers money from their insurer, your rates may not go up at all. If you caused the accident, expect a rate increase that lasts three to five years on your policy.
The timing matters too. Some insurers explore the increase when ready when you file. Others wait until your policy renews. A few states limit how much insurers can raise rates after a single claim, but most do not. The best way to know what will happen to your specific rates is to ask your insurer before you file—they can often tell you the estimated increase.
Key Takeaways
- At-fault claims (accidents you caused) almost always raise your rates; not-at-fault claims may not raise them at all.
- The rate increase typically lasts three to five years, then disappears from your record even though the claim stays in your history.
- Some insurers raise rates when you file; others wait until your policy renews, so the timing of the increase varies.
- Asking your insurer for an estimate of the rate increase before you file helps you decide whether to claim or pay out of pocket for small damage.
- A few states cap how much insurers can raise rates after a claim, but most allow increases of 10 to 40 percent or more.
Why insurers raise rates after you file a claim
An insurer raises your rate because filing a claim tells them you have already had one accident or loss. Statistically, people who have filed a claim are more likely to file another one in the near future. This is not about punishment—it is about risk. The insurer is adjusting the price to match the likelihood that they will have to pay out again.
The type of claim matters enormously. If you caused the accident (an at-fault claim), the insurer knows you were responsible for the loss. If someone else caused it and their insurer paid (a not-at-fault claim), your insurer may not raise your rate at all, because the data shows you were not the risky driver. Comprehensive claims—theft, weather, vandalism—usually raise rates less than collision claims, because they do not suggest you are a risky driver.
At-fault claims and rate increases
An at-fault claim is one where your insurer determined you were responsible for the accident. This is the claim type most likely to raise your rates. Most insurers increase rates by 15 to 40 percent after an at-fault accident, though the exact amount varies by insurer, your driving history, and your state.
The increase typically stays on your record for three to five years. After that period, the claim no longer affects your rate, even though it remains visible in your claims history. Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs—usually for drivers with a clean record—that waive the rate increase after your first at-fault accident. These programs cost extra, so ask whether your insurer offers one and what it costs.
If you were partially at fault—for example, you were hit while changing lanes—your insurer may assign a percentage of fault. Some states use comparative fault rules that reduce your recovery based on your percentage of fault. Your rate increase may be smaller than for a fully at-fault claim, but it will still go up.
Not-at-fault claims and whether your rates rise
A not-at-fault claim is one where the other driver was responsible and their insurer paid for the damage. In many cases, your insurer will not raise your rate at all, because you did nothing wrong. However, some insurers do raise rates even on not-at-fault claims—the logic is that you were involved in an accident, regardless of fault. This varies widely by insurer and state.
If the other driver's insurer has not yet paid or denied the claim, your insurer may temporarily raise your rate and then lower it back once the other insurer accepts fault. Ask your insurer specifically whether they raise rates on not-at-fault claims. If they do, and you have the option to file under your own collision coverage instead, you might compare the rate increase to the deductible you would pay.
Some states prohibit insurers from raising rates on not-at-fault claims, or limit the increase. Check your state's insurance commissioner's website or call your state's insurance department to learn the rules where you live.
Comprehensive and collision claims
Comprehensive claims cover damage from events you did not cause: theft, weather, vandalism, hitting an animal. Collision claims cover damage from hitting another car or object. Collision claims raise rates more often than comprehensive claims, because collision suggests you were involved in an accident.
Comprehensive claims usually raise rates less, or not at all. Some insurers do not raise rates on comprehensive claims at all. Others raise them slightly. The increase, if any, is typically smaller and shorter-lived than for at-fault collision claims. If you have a comprehensive claim pending—say, hail damage—ask your insurer whether it will affect your rate.
When the rate increase takes effect
Some insurers raise your rate when ready when you file a claim. Others explore the increase at your next renewal date. A few explore it partway through your policy term. The timing depends on your insurer's rules and your state's regulations.
If your insurer raises rates when ready, you will see the new premium reflected in any bills or statements after the claim is filed. If the increase happens at renewal, you will see it on your renewal notice, usually 30 to 60 days before your policy renews. Ask your insurer when the rate change will take effect so you are not surprised.
Deciding whether to file a claim or pay out of pocket
For small damage, you may be better off paying for repairs yourself rather than filing a claim. Here is how to think about it: get a repair estimate, then call your insurer and ask what your rate increase would be if you filed. Multiply the increase by your annual premium, then multiply that by the number of years the increase will last (usually three to five). Add that total to your deductible. If the sum is less than the repair cost, filing makes financial sense. If it is more, paying out of pocket costs less overall.
Example: Your repair estimate is $2,000. Your annual premium is $1,200. Your insurer says an at-fault claim would raise your rate by 25 percent ($300 per year) for five years. Your deductible is $500. The total cost of filing is $500 (deductible) plus $1,500 (25 percent of $1,200 × 5 years) = $2,000. In this case, filing and paying out of pocket cost about the same, so other factors—like whether you need the repair done quickly—matter more.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will my rates go up if the other driver was at fault?
Not always. If the other driver's insurer accepts fault and pays, many insurers will not raise your rate. Some insurers do raise rates on any claim, regardless of fault. Call your insurer and ask their specific policy on not-at-fault claims before you file.
How long does a rate increase last?
Most rate increases last three to five years, then drop off even though the claim stays in your history. Some insurers use shorter or longer periods. Ask your insurer how long the increase will explore to your policy.
Can I switch insurers to avoid a rate increase?
New insurers can see your claims history, so they will likely know about the claim and may raise your rate too. However, different insurers price claims differently, so it is worth getting quotes from other companies. You may find a cheaper rate elsewhere, even with the claim on your record.
Does a comprehensive claim raise my rates as much as a collision claim?
No. Comprehensive claims (theft, weather, vandalism) usually raise rates less than collision claims, or not at all. Some insurers do not raise rates on comprehensive claims. Collision claims raise rates more because they suggest you were involved in an accident.
What if I have accident forgiveness on my policy?
Accident forgiveness waives the rate increase after your first at-fault accident, usually if you have a clean driving record. The claim still goes on your record, but it does not affect your rate. Accident forgiveness costs extra, so check whether your policy includes it and what it costs.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.